I Heart London by Lindsey Kelk Review 1/5

Overall Impression: Selfishness runs riot in this lackluster installment of one of my favourite series.I Heart London by Lindsey Kelk

‘Ohh dear’ is pretty much the phrase I would use to sum up this book, perhaps with an ‘exasperated’ or ‘deflated’ on the side. Seriously, Lindsey Kelk, what the heck happened with this book? Over the past year the I Heart series (of which I Heart London is the 5th book) has become my go-to for when I’m in the mood for something lightweight, fun and romantic that is farfetched but in the best possible way.
Unfortunately, this installment didn’t deliver on any of the above, and instead left me fuming and disappointed. In other words: I has a sad. And an angry. (This will probably be more of a rant than a review.)

Home is where the heart is. Right?
Angela Clark has fallen in love with New York – and it’s starting to love her back. But when she’s summoned home to England, she’s at risk of losing her shiny life to rain, warm beer and bad memories.
Talk about stepping back in time.
There’s Mark, the ex-boyfriend – who she ran to New York to get away from.
There’s Louisa, her best friend, with her terrifying new baby.
And there’s her mum, still talking to her as though she’s fifteen.
Now there’s a wedding in the offering – and everyone remembers how well Angela behaved at the last one…
Can the arrival of boyfriend Alex and new best friend Jenny save her from a re-run of her old self?

Please note: this review does contain some spoilers which are clearly marked so you can skip them!

It seems Lindsey Kelk is one of those authors that when she gets it right, she gets it marvelously right, but when she gets it wrong… oh man, she nose dives, crashes and burns. Like Kelk’s previous novels her writing in I Heart London is basic, and she spends more time describing shoes and Marc Jacob’s bags than she does adding to character depth and forming an intriguing plot – but that’s okay. This genre doesn’t rely on these things as much as others do and are not vital to making a book like this work. What is vital however, is the ability provide some laugh out loud moments and witty observations about everyday life, the ability to make the reader swoon at the romantic interest, and most importantly, you have to be able to get behind the main character and root for them to succeed. These are things that Kelk usually showcases so well but were completely lacking in I Heart London. I think I laughed maybe once, I definitely didn’t feel chemistry with the romance despite Angela and Alex being on of my FAVOURITE drool worthy fictional couples, and I’m pretty sure I wanted to slap the main character within the first three pages and the urge did not distill after I closed the cover… or even 3 hours after I had finished the damn thing!

This book just hit all the wrong notes for me, which I was shocked by because I was looking forward to this installment the most. I thought Angela returning home would be a really interesting and action-packed installment where she would have to confront all the fears and realities she ran away from, but most of this is sidestepped in favour of *drum roll*…

Wedding planning.

Yepp. This book basically felt like an unentertaining episode of Don’t Tell the Bride, but instead of the groom planning the wedding it was Angela’s turbulent friend, Jenny. This entire book pretty much consisted of the characters sitting around arguing about planning Angela’s trip down the aisle and making lots of phone calls. It wasn’t even about the interesting aspects of planning a wedding! The novel had no point of conflict apart from Angela’s two best friends bickering (which Angela could have prevented if she’d stopped to reassure her friends they weren’t being replaced for like 2 seconds) and Angela seeing her ex. It had a non-existent plot and…


This entire book is basically pointless because all the snore worthy wedding planning doesn’t even lead up to anything –  at the last minute before guests arrive they decide to cancel it. YOU SERIOUSLY MADE ME SIT THROUGH ALL OF THAT AND THEN YOU DIDN’T EVEN GIVE ME A FLIPPIN’ CHEESY WEDDING AT THE END OF IT KELK, WHAT THE HELL. The final chapter cuts to a ‘3 months later’ where the actual wedding takes place and you don’t get to see any of it. Oh so satisfying. Not.


My irritations about the lack of plot were only irked further by Angela’s constant moaning. She somehow manages to complain and whine her way through the entire story despite the fact that she has created a dream life where she lives in one of the most amazing cities in the world (New York), has the job she has always wanted doing what she loves and is about to get promoted, AND is about to get married to a gorgeous rockstar. It made me want to punch something. On top of that, she regularly lashes out at her parents every time they speak and dare to take even the slightest interest in her life after not seeing her for two years, and all I could think was, you could have parents who don’t care, you could have parents who wouldn’t be willing to pay for your dream wedding, or you could not have parents at all. Take a chill pill and appreciate what you have, because most people aren’t so lucky you ungrateful, selfish person.

It’s safe to say I didn’t enjoy Angela’s character development in this one, she makes the same mistakes she has in all the previous novels showing she clearly hasn’t learnt anything. She spends the whole novel wondering why her friend Jenny is so upset when it is blatantly obvious. She let’s her new best friend, Jenny say horrendous things to her UK best friend, Louisa that are totally unacceptable and doesn’t defend her or do anything about it, which is shocking as they’ve been friends since school whereas she’s only known Jenny two years (come to think of it, a lot of my dislike of this novel comes from how horrifically Angela treats her two best friends and everyone else around her). Jenny is almost as awful, lashing out at others because she’s heartbroken, while Louisa is equally unpleasant as the jealous friend (although for good reason). Meanwhile, Alex was still his same, charming self, but I don’t feel like he was given enough of a storyline.

Overall, it’s safe to say I did not enjoy I Heart London, with Angela acting like a spoilt brat and the basically non-existent plot which spent the whole novel building up to something which turned out to be unsatisfying, this book was a big miss for me, and even though I tried REALLY hard to find something I liked about it I couldn’t, which is why this book is getting 1 star. I hope Kelk will be back to her normal form in the next installment because I really do love this series and I’ve given all of the other books good ratings (Two five stars for starters!) but sadly, I Heart London gets a big thumbs down from me. However, I would recommend this series to anyone who loves far-fetched but fun escapism.

Writing Style: 3/5
Originality: 1/5
Entertainment: 1/5
Character Development: 1/5
Would I recommend this book? No, but the rest of the series, yes.

Overall: 1/5

18 thoughts on “I Heart London by Lindsey Kelk Review 1/5

  1. Oh, feel the burrrnnn! {cackles}

    For a bit of escapism, have you ever tried Janet Evanovich – “One for the money”, “Two for the dough”, etc. A woman down on her luck tries bounty hunting… You might enjoy the triangle tug between the main characters.

    If you try them out, start with “Two” though – “One” is quite dark and violent.

    • Eeep. Yes. I did get quite annoyed at this one. I was mostly frustrated because the other books in the series have been SO good, so I just couldn’t understand what happened with this one!

      I’ve never heard of Janet Evanovitch but the storyline sounds quite fun, I’d be interested to see how that would play out!

  2. This sounds like the book I read not so long ago. No character development, an irksome protagonist, and no real storyline. It’s why I USUALLY steer clear of the genre. But it sounds like this series was doing so well for a while.
    It also kind of sounds like Kelk was phoning it in for this one, just to fulfil a contract obligation.
    I hope the series improves for you!

    • Oh no, sorry to hear you’ve felt the same kind of frustrating book pain recently. As a general rule I stay away from this genre too, I don’t get on with 99% of them. Lindsey Kelk is normally the 1%, but something went very, very wrong this time!
      Yeah, it did feel a bit like that, but the weird thing is I thought this would be the story she would have the most material for, and somehow it turned out to be the opposite. :/
      Thank you, I hope so too!

      • I hate laziness in authors. I mean, they become successful for a reason. And when the authors start forgetting that, start phoning it in, that’s when they’ve forgotten what an author’s primary job is.
        It hurts me because I know so many brilliant writers who may never get a publishing deal and yet successful authors get to phone it in and publish drivel AND get paid for it? No!

      • Eeep, yes. It is a sad, sad thing. Luckily with the books I’ve read, I’ve only really encountered that problem once, but it does really show.
        The publishing world is a tough cookie to crack, and it’s sad that not enough people read books in order to be able to get more people published (if the book industry had as much money as the make-up industry think of the awesome!).
        I hope your friends don’t despair and keep trying. 🙂

  3. I give this book five stars for the passion it evoked in Becky, after all passion is passion whether the literature evoked good or bad its job could be said to be done. though I would have thought the review would elicit more comment, early days, perhaps time will bring agreement 😉
    Excellent review

    • Hmm, that’s an interesting way of putting it, I suppose any reaction you get to an author at least shows that they are able to make you feel something.

      Nah, books that are part of a series always get less comments because people aren’t clued into the story. 🙂

      Thank you!

  4. 1 star – ouch!
    I won’t be rushing out to get this one. I enjoyed I Heart New York but even the events of I Heart Hollywood started to get ridiculous, no matter how much I tried to suspend my disbelief, and while I did enjoy that one too, despite how silly and farfetched it was, I’m not sure I care to go any further with these books.
    When you get the urge to slap the main character, you know you’re in trouble. So Angela’s a non-stop whiner here and there are no laughs. Thanks for the heads-up, Becky. I’ll be staying well clear.

    • Yepp! This was an ouch kinda book. :/

      Kelk definitely does tread a fine line with the authenticity of her storylines, despite the kind of wish fulfillment element of chick-lit, some of the events are so unbelievable it does start to get a bit annoying. I have to say, I loved I Heart Paris, the next book after Hollywood and thought it was the best one, so I would 100% recommend that one! But yeah, I get what you mean, this is definitely a series you can easily pick up or leave because each story wraps up nicely.

      Unfortunately, I feel like all the weakness of the series were made really apparent in this one, but I’ll still be giving her book I Heart Christmas a chance. 🙂

  5. I’ve read ‘I Heart New York’ and thought it was a really decent chick-lit book, but I guessed that this series could have the potential to take a nose-dive! I think using the same characters and the same premise for an entire book series requires the plot to be OUTSTANDING for each story, otherwise it would just lead to mediocre nothingness.

    Point proven! Hopefully it won’t taint your love of the other I Heart books…

    • I Heart New York was a great chick lit book, and the rest of the series has been awesome too right up to this book! Maybe you’re right and having the same premise used to repeatedly is eventually going to wear thin. I really hope the next book in the series picks up. Thank you, me too!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s